Listen to this article
The whole article read aloud, about 5 minutes
The audio could not be played here. Open this page in Chrome or Safari and try again.
If the vehicle that caused an accident was driven without a licence, or was running outside the route on its permit, the insurer cannot simply refuse the victim’s compensation by pointing to that breach. A Claims Tribunal or court can order the insurer to pay the victim first and then recover the money from the vehicle owner — the “pay and recover” rule. On 29 October 2025 the Supreme Court upheld exactly this for a bus that had left its permitted route (K. Nagendra, 2025 INSC 1270).
The case in short
On 7 October 2014, a bus hit a man riding a motorcycle in Channapatna, Karnataka; he died on the spot. The bus held a permit for the Bengaluru–Mysore route only and was not allowed into Channapatna town. The insurer argued that this permit breach freed it from paying. The Karnataka High Court raised the compensation to ₹31,84,000 and told the insurer to pay it and recover the amount from the bus owner (judgment paras 2–5).
The Supreme Court agreed, for two reasons (paras 9–10):
- For the victim: the accident was not the victim’s fault. Denying the family compensation because the bus was outside its permit “would be offensive to the sense of justice”. So the insurer must pay.
- For the insurer: a policy is a contract with limits, and making the insurer finally bear a loss outside those limits would be unfair. Hence the right to recover from the owner.
What the law says
Under the Motor Vehicles Act, an insurer must pay third-party victims the amount of a court judgment or tribunal award against its policyholder, even where it could avoid or cancel the policy. After the 2019 amendment this sits in Section 150(1); the judgment refers to the older Section 149 because the accident happened in 2014. Section 150(2) lists the only grounds on which the insurer may defend itself, including:
- a transport vehicle used for a purpose its permit does not allow; hire or reward without a permit for it; racing or speed testing
- driving by someone without a valid licence or while disqualified; drunk or drugged driving under Section 185
- a policy obtained by hiding or misstating a material fact; premium not received
Even when such a defence succeeds, the Tribunal may direct the insurer to pay first and recover later — the Supreme Court said so in Swaran Singh (2004), quoted at para 7.1 of the 2025 judgment. The insurer’s right to recover also appears in the policy itself: IRDAI’s standard private car / two-wheeler policy has an “Avoidance of certain terms and right of recovery” clause, under which the policyholder must repay what the insurer paid only because the law required it (IRDAI standard motor policy, page 2, Section I clause 7).
Where the Supreme Court has applied it
The 2025 judgment (paras 5.2 and 7.1–7.5) recalls these earlier situations:
| Situation | Supreme Court case (as cited in the judgment) |
|---|---|
| Driver without a valid licence | Parminder Singh (2019); Kamla (2001) |
| Licence for one class of vehicle, driving another | S. Iyyapan (2013) |
| Vehicle carrying hazardous goods it was not authorised to carry | Chatha Service Station (2025) |
| Vehicle with no permit at all | Amrit Paul (2018), relied on by the High Court |
| Bus off its permitted route | K. Nagendra (29-10-2025) |
A worked example
(Imaginary, to show the steps. In a real case the Tribunal decides the amount and who pays, on the evidence.)
In Karimnagar, Swathi is walking home when a goods auto knocks her down and she breaks her leg. The auto’s owner is Ramesh; it was being driven by a helper, Babu, who has no driving licence. The auto has third-party insurance.
- Swathi files a claim before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal; the owner, the driver and the insurer become parties.
- The insurer pleads “unlicensed driver” — a defence under Section 150(2)(a)(ii).
- Suppose the Tribunal awards ₹4 lakh. With a pay-and-recover order, the insurer pays Swathi ₹4 lakh plus any interest awarded.
- The insurer then recovers that sum from Ramesh. Swathi does not have to chase Ramesh for the money.
If you or your family are the victims
- Where to file: the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT) — your choice of the one covering the place of the accident, the place where you live or work, or the place where the other side lives (Section 166(2)).
- Who can file: the injured person; the legal representatives if the person died; or an agent they authorise (Section 166(1)).
- Do not delay: the 2019 amendment added a six-month limit for filing from the date of the accident (Section 166(3)). We could not confirm from an official notification the date from which this provision applies, so file as early as you can.
- Don’t know the insurer? The owner must tell the Tribunal whether the vehicle was insured on the accident date and with which company (Section 150(6)).
- Papers usually needed: FIR or police accident report, medical records and bills, post-mortem report in a death case, proof of income. Ask your lawyer or the District Legal Services Authority what your Tribunal requires.
- If someone tells you “no licence, no permit, so no compensation”, that is not the final word — the Tribunal decides.
If you own the vehicle
- Insurance does not make it safe to let anyone drive. If an unlicensed person drives, or a transport vehicle goes outside its permit, the insurer can pay the victim and then recover the full amount — possibly lakhs — from you.
- IRDAI’s standard policy covers driving by a person with a valid licence, or a learner who meets Rule 3 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules (standard policy, pages 15–16, Driver clause).
- Check the licence before you hand over your vehicle; run a transport vehicle only on the route and for the purpose in its permit.
- In Kamla (2001) the Court left it open to an owner to argue before the Tribunal that he made due enquiries and honestly believed his paid driver was licensed; it did not decide that point (para 7.2 of the 2025 judgment). Keeping a copy of your driver’s licence is sensible either way.
Key terms
| Term | Plain meaning |
|---|---|
| Pay and recover | The insurer pays the victim first and later collects the same amount from the vehicle owner |
| MACT | Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, which hears road-accident compensation cases |
| Third party | An outside person harmed by your vehicle |
| Permit | Transport department permission saying where and for what a bus, taxi or goods vehicle may run |
| Award | The Tribunal’s compensation order |
| Legal representatives | The heirs entitled to claim for a person who died |
Myths and facts
| Myth | Fact |
|---|---|
| “The driver had no licence, so the victim gets nothing.” | The Tribunal can order the insurer to pay first; the Supreme Court has upheld pay-and-recover in such cases. |
| “After this judgment, owners are off the hook.” | No. The judgment upheld the insurer’s right to recover the money from the owner. |
| “It applies even when the vehicle had no insurance.” | It is about insured vehicles. An uninsured vehicle is a different situation. |
| “The insurer always pays first.” | Not guaranteed. The Tribunal or court decides on the facts. |
Related: why third-party insurance is compulsory and the four-part motor policy from 15 December 2026.
Sources
- Supreme Court judgment: K. Nagendra vs The New India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors., SLP (C) Nos. 7139–7140 of 2023, 29-10-2025, 2025 INSC 1270, paras 2–10. Official copy: Supreme Court website — search by judgment date 29-10-2025
- Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act 2019, Gazette: Section 150 (insurer’s duty to satisfy judgments and awards, permitted defences, 150(6)); amendment of Section 166 (166(3) six months)
- Motor Vehicles Act 1988 (India Code): Sections 166(1) and 166(2)
- IRDAI standard motor policy (private car / two-wheeler), annexure to circular of 02-11-2026: page 2 (right of recovery), pages 15–16 (Driver clause)
All sources above were checked on 8 November 2026. Last updated: 8 November 2026.
